Sunday, November 8, 2020

Nemesis: Alcibiades and the Fall of Athens (brief review)

Stuttard, David. Nemesis : Alcibiades and the fall of Athens. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 2018.

David Stuttard writes like an angel. His biography of Alcibiades is engaging, novelistic in its characteristization and setting, but unquestionably faithful to the historical sources. 

Alcibiades chiefly interests me as a one-time protege and associate of Socrates. Alcibiades was just the sort of young man who interested the Gadfly of Athens: young, handsome, aristocratic, intelligent. That Alcibiades proved so unreceptive to the ethical precepts of his would-be teacher undoubtedly played a part in Socrates' trial and execution. 

Alcibiades flits across the Mediterranean world, making and breaking promises in Athens, Sparta, Ionia, and Thrace. He beds a Spartan queen, provoking a constituional crisis. He makes pacts with democrats and oligarchs, with little regard for ideological consistency. He takes male and female lovers. He aspires to the rule of the Mediterranean, but ends his life as a Thracian princeling and Persian petty-lord. His life is one of extraordinary contrasts: at home everywhere and nowhere. He's finally ambushed by his Persian overlord and dies rushing his assasins, naked and bereft of weapons. 

Nemesis is just the sort of history I enjoy: entirely old-fashioned in its concern with great men, wars, and the arts and marvelously well-written. David Stuttard has shown himself to be a master of the genre; I await with anticipation any future work in the field.