Showing posts with label 2020. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2020. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 10, 2020

Why Socrates Died (brief review)

 


Waterfield, Robin. Why Socrates died : dispelling the myths. New York: W.W. Norton & Co, 2009.

After reading David Stuttard's biography of Alcibiades, I wanted to take another look at the political and social context for the execution of Socrates. Fortunately, I had a book to hand. 

Robin Waterfield is a prolific translator; I own several works translated by him, many of them in the Oxford World Classics series. In Why Socrates Died, he provides an overview of the Peloponessian War, its effects on the Athenian polity, and Socrates' relationship with many of the prime movers and shakers, including Alcibiades. 

Waterfield provides valuable information about the procedural form of an Athenian trial, the composition of the jury, and the range of punishments. He also discusses at length the charges of impiety. In ancient Athens, politics and religion were inextricably intertwined: failure to offer fitting sacrifice to the gods of the city posed a threat to the well-being of the city. Socrates held some unconventional religious views. By charging him with impiety, his prosecutors muddied the waters, appealing to the conservative religious instincts of the jury. The real attack lay elsewhere. 

In Waterfield's telling, Socrates was condemned on account of the company he kept: he had longstanding ties with several ambitious aristocratic politicians, most notably Alcibiades and Critias. Alcibiades' peccadilloes are well-known, and he served as the poster boy of aristocratic bad behavior. In the restored Athenian democracy, he was a byword for bad faith. Critias, another Socratic associate, was the mastermind by the Spartan-backed rule of the Thirty Tyrants, who launched a brutal campaign of assassination and repression. Their downfall and the restoration of democracy had only taken place four years before Socrates' trial and execution. Socrates' associates were bad enough, but he was also a well-known critic of democracy. The Socratic position was nuanced, but to a jury composed of artisans and laborers, his sympathies would have seemed suspiciously oligarchic. 

In the last chapter, Waterfield posits an interesting hypothesis: after years of see-sawing between oligarchy and democracy, the execution of Socrates functioned as a sacrifical scapegoat, a means of binding the city into a new unanimity. If that was indeed the case, it would have appeared to work. Athens retained its democracy for 80 years following the death of Socrates. 

Sunday, November 8, 2020

A Secular Age (brief review)

 

Taylor, Charles. A secular age. Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007.

Clocking in at 776 pages, sans endnotes, Charles Taylor's A Secular Age is a doorstopping work. It sat, unread, on my bookshelf for over a decade, not least because of its formidable length. I regret not reading it sooner. 

Unfortunately, I didn't have the time or energy to make extended notes, so my few comments here cannot do the work anything like the justice it requires. Instead, I'll offer a few stray thoughts which were occasioned by my reading and which struck me as particularly relevant to my own situation. 

Parts I and II of A Secular Age attempt a master-narrative of secularization. Secularity, in Taylor's usage, doesn't merely mean the elimination or subsidence of religious belief; secularity, rather, is the creation of a contested environment, where belief and unbelief co-exist in an atmosphere of give and take. Taylor's account, then, tries to make sense of the history of this kind of secularization. He calls this history the Reform Master Narrative. I confess that these parts were least interesting to me. I certainly learned a great deal, but I struggled to finish certain sections and was least struck by their originality. His account of the "buffered" or impervious self was perhaps most intriguing. A buffered self is one closed off to the forms of enchantment which prior generations of humans would have experienced as normative. They live in a flat world and a linear time and only rarely experience a fleeting intrusion of some higher time. 

My interest, however, began to peak in Part III. Using an astronomical metaphor, Taylor calls the explosion of possible positions between belief and unbelief the Nova Effect: from orthodox belief to the more conventional forms of Enlightenment unbelief (Voltaire) and the rebellions it spawned, Romanticism (Hegel, Wordsworth) and the immanent counter-Enlightenment (Nietzsche). Taylor's phenomenology of belief/unbelief here is striking, and by describing the various poles around which an individual might cluster and the multifarious influences which might come to bear on that individual, I could recognize my own experience. Hardcover believers and unabashed unbelievers exist, undoubtedly, but for a great many people, the situation is more complex. They live under the "cross-pressures" of modernity, buffeted by the temptations of belief and unbelief alike. This very cross-pressure drives the creation of newer and newer positions existing along the continuum between the two poles. 

Part IV tries to make sense of the contemporary religious environment and to give an account of its diversity. Taylor takes up an old theme of his: authenticity. The quest for authenticity is the driving need of our time: everyone wants to achieve a life of complete realization, to be fully oneself. This need for authenticity is hard to square with orthodox belief, but it also poses problems for exclusive humanism as well. 

Part V was the most compelling section of the book. I read it rapidly and with great interest. Taylor continues here his work of complicating conventional narratives of secularization. I think he also offers a muted, but nonethless powerful, apologia for Christian belief. He looks at some of the dilemmas which confront believers and unbelievers alike: the desire for fulness, the pain of loss and the inevitability of death, violence and war. His purpose here is to refute casual explanations of these phenomena, those which are most likely to appeal to fundamentalist believers and unbelievers alike. He also takes various modern writers and thinkers as examples of the possibilities open to believers in the secular age. His accounts of Maritain, Peguy, and Gerard Manley Hopkins are especially enlightening. Maritain gave up his dreams of a restored Christendom and worked tirelessly to delineate new possibilities for the Christian believers in an age of increasing unbelief. Peguy was a more unconventional believer, but he also created an idiosyncratic path for himself, one which combined his Christian orthodoxy with a socialist energy and a patriotic fidelity to the French nation. In his poetry, Hopkins gives form to new registers of Christian belief: he combines a Romantic love of nature with Christian orthodoxy and explores new resonances of language. Taylor's exemplars of belief in the secular age are believers who find new and creative possibilities for the exploitation of the full range of the Christian message. It is clear that Taylor by no means believes in a declinist account of the Church: on the contrary, he sees new paths everywhere. 

Finally, in his Epilogue, Taylor relates his own work to that of other theorists in the field: he contrasts his account of a Reform Master Narrative with the Intellectual Deviation Narrative. He confesses that he largely agrees with the ID account, but he was unsatisfied with the ways in which it attempted to explain how unbelief passed from a learned elite to the masses; his work is meant to be complementary: both accounts are necessary for understanding how we arrived at a secular age. 

Nemesis: Alcibiades and the Fall of Athens (brief review)

Stuttard, David. Nemesis : Alcibiades and the fall of Athens. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 2018.

David Stuttard writes like an angel. His biography of Alcibiades is engaging, novelistic in its characteristization and setting, but unquestionably faithful to the historical sources. 

Alcibiades chiefly interests me as a one-time protege and associate of Socrates. Alcibiades was just the sort of young man who interested the Gadfly of Athens: young, handsome, aristocratic, intelligent. That Alcibiades proved so unreceptive to the ethical precepts of his would-be teacher undoubtedly played a part in Socrates' trial and execution. 

Alcibiades flits across the Mediterranean world, making and breaking promises in Athens, Sparta, Ionia, and Thrace. He beds a Spartan queen, provoking a constituional crisis. He makes pacts with democrats and oligarchs, with little regard for ideological consistency. He takes male and female lovers. He aspires to the rule of the Mediterranean, but ends his life as a Thracian princeling and Persian petty-lord. His life is one of extraordinary contrasts: at home everywhere and nowhere. He's finally ambushed by his Persian overlord and dies rushing his assasins, naked and bereft of weapons. 

Nemesis is just the sort of history I enjoy: entirely old-fashioned in its concern with great men, wars, and the arts and marvelously well-written. David Stuttard has shown himself to be a master of the genre; I await with anticipation any future work in the field.